Zancolli Lasso Technique Versus Brand Technique in Hand Clawing: A Comparative Study of Functional Outcomes

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 The Department of Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Tanta University

2 The Department of General Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Tanta University

Abstract

Background: Ulnar nerve palsy has a negative impact on
basic daily activities. The ulnar nerve lesions seem to be far
worse than the median and radial nerves. Tendon transfer
offers the sole solution in neglected cases of ulnar nerve
injuries by providing active-controlled motion. Tendon transfers
are performed to eradicate claw deformity and restore hand
grip.
Objective: To evaluate the effectiveness of the Zancolli
Lasso procedure (ZLP) vs. Brand technique "Extensor Carpi
Radialis Longus Transfer" in treating hand clawing.
Patients and Methods: Twenty patients who suffered from
isolated ulnar nerve palsy, regardless the level of injury, with
hand clawing after one year or more from the initial injury
time with no clinical signs of nerve recovery participated in
this prospective study. Ten patients were operated on using
the Zancolli Lasso procedure (group A), and ten patients used
Extensor Carpi Radialis longus tendon transfer (group B).
Prior to and following surgery, patients underwent both
subjective and objective evaluations.
Results: Group A showed significantly shorter operative
time, while Group B showed better Hand Assessment Tool
(HAT) score and hand grip measurements. Both groups showed
significant differences in the variable PIP and DIP joint range
of motion.
Conclusion: ZLP is an easier surgical choice for claw
deformity correction with shorter operative time, while ECRL
bestows better handgrip improvement and patient-reported
outcomes. Thus, ECRL is favored in manual workers, whereas
ZLP is favored in patients with medical comorbidities whenever
a shorter operative time is recommended.

Keywords

Main Subjects


McCormick C.A., Rath S., Patra P.N., Pereira J. and
Wilkinson M.: A qualitative study of common functional
problems experienced by people with complete ulnar
nerve paralysis. Lepr. Rev., 79 (2): 154-61, 2008.
2- Murovic J.A.: Upper-extremity peripheral nerve injuries:
a Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center
literature review comparing the operative outcomes of
1837 Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center
median, radial and ulnar nerve lesions. Neurosurgery,
Oct. 65 (4 Suppl): A11-7, 2009.
3- Lan C.Y., Tien H.Y., Lin Y. Te, Hsu C.C., Lin C.H. and
Chen S.H.: Prognosis of Traumatic Ulnar Nerve Injuries:
A Systematic Review. Ann. Plast. Surg., 82 (1S Suppl 1):
S45-52, 2019.
4- Diaz-Garcia R.J. and Chung K.C.: A Comprehensive
Guide on Restoring Grasp Using Tendon Transfer Procedures
for Ulnar Nerve Palsy. Hand Clin., 32 (3): 361-8,
2016.
5- Gardenier J., Garg R. and Mudgal C.: Upper extremity
tendon transfers: A brief review of history, common
applications, and technical tips. Indian Journal of Plastic
Surgery, 53 (2): 177-90, 2020.
6- Zancolli E.A.: Claw-Hand Caused by Paralysis of the
Intrinsic Muscles. J Bone Joint Surg., 39 (5): 1076-80.
7- Brand P.W.: Tendon Grafting Illustrated by a New Operation
for Intrinsic Paralysis of the Fingers. Journal of
Bone and Joint Surgery-British Volume, 444-53, 1961.
Egypt, J. Plast. Reconstr. Surg., October 2023 317
8- Özkan T., Özer K. and Gülgönen A.: Three tendon transfer
methods in the reconstruction of ulnar nerve palsy. Journal
of Hand Surgery, 28 (1): 35-43, 2003.
9- White D.J.: The Hand. In: Norkin C.C., White D.J., editors.
Measurement of Joint Motion: A Guide to Goniometry,
5e. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Education, 2016.
10- Rantanen T., Guralnik J.M., Sakari-rantala R., Simonsick
E.M., Ling S. and Fried L.I.: Disability, Physical Activity,
and Muscle Strength in Older Women: The Women's
Health and Aging Study, 80 (February): 130-5, 1999.
11- Naidu S.H., Panchik D. and Chinchilli V.M.: Development
and Validation of the Hand Assessment Tool. Journal of
Hand Therapy, 22 (3): 250-7, 2009.
12- Vastamäki M., Kallio P.K. and Solonen K.A.: The results
of secondary microsurgical repair of ulnar nerve injury.
J. Hand Surg. Br., Jun. 18 (3): 323-6, 1993.
13- Jaquet J.B., Luijsterburg A.J., Kalmijn S., Kuypers P.D.,
Hofman A. and Hovius S.E.: Median, ulnar, and combined
median-ulnar nerve injuries: Functional outcome and
return to productivity. J. Trauma, Oct. 51 (4): 687-92,
2001.
14- Domeshek L.F., Novak CB, Patterson J.M.M., Hasak J.M.,
Yee A., Kahn L.C., et al.: Nerve Transfers-A Paradigm
Shift in the Reconstructive Ladder. Plast. Reconstr. Surg.
Glob Open, Jun. 7 (6): e2290, 2019.
15- Gottschalk H.P. and Bindra R.R.: Late Reconstruction of
Ulnar Nerve Palsy. Orthopedic Clinics of North America,
43 (4): 495-507, 2012.
16- Riordan D.C.: Tendon transfers in hand surgery. Journal
of Hand Surgery [Internet], 8 (5): 748-53. Available from:
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S0363-5023(83)80264-0, 1983.
17- Abd Elmoktader M.A., Mekky M., Sholkamy K. and
Nageh M.: Evaluation of Different Modalities of Tendon
Transfer in Ulnar Nerve Palsy. Egypt J. Hosp. Med., 75
(6): 3000-5, 2019.
18- Verma C.V., Bhosale K.S., Thatte M.R. and Sawant A.D.:
Outcomes of Tendon Transfer Surgery for Correction of
Ulnar Claw Hand: A Case Series. J. Hand Surg. Glob.
Online, 1-8, 2022.
19- Baltzer H, Woo A., Oh C. and Moran S.L.: Comparison
of Ulnar Intrinsic Function Following Supercharge Endto-
Side Anterior Interosseous-to-Ulnar Motor Nerve
Transfer. Plast. Reconstr. Surg., Dec. 138 (6): 1264-72,
2016.
20- Brandsma J.W. and Ottenhoff-DE Jonge M.W.: Flexor
Digitorum Superficialis Tendon Transfer for Intrinsic
Replacement. Journal of Hand Surgery, 17 (6): 625-8,
1992.